Home Equity Theft: When Does The “Takings Clause” Become The “Bend Over & Take It Clause”
Today on Legalese we will be taking a look at the legalized armed robbery that constitutes “Equity Asset Theft”
Last week, the Supreme Court agreed to grant cert on the merits for the case “Tyler v. City of Minneapolis”. This case challenges the constitutionality of a Minnesota state law empowering local governments to seize the entire value of a property in order to pay off a much smaller delinquent property tax debt. The property owner in the case—93-year-old widow Geraldine Tyler—argues that this kind of uncompensated seizure of home equity violates the Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment, which requires government to pay “just compensation” anytime it takes private property, and the Excessive Fines Clause of the Eighth Amendment.
So how does home equity theft actually work? How does the government justify this policy which stands in clear contravention to the 5th and 8th amendment’s takings clause & excessive fines clause (respectively).
We will discuss the likely outcome of the case as well as the broader implications that this potential landmark 5th amendment case will have.
Creation, Consent, and Government Power over Property Rights – https://www.cato-unbound.org/2010/12/13/ilya-somin/creation-consent-government-power-over-property-rights/
Hall v. Meisner, Sixth Circuit Opinion (2022) -https://www.opn.ca6.uscourts.gov/opinions.pdf/22a0226p-06.pdf
Tyler v. Hennepin County, Eighth Circuit Opinion (2021) – https://ecf.ca8.uscourts.gov/opndir/22/02/203730P.pdf
Pacific Legal Foundation – https://pacificlegal.org/
Tyler v. Hennepin County: Summary of Fact (Pacific Legal Foundation) – https://pacificlegal.org/case/mn_home_equity_theft/
Tyler v. Hennepin County Cert Petition – https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/22/22-166/233999/20220819120827692_TylerPWCFinal.pdf
Follow & Support
Legalese Home Page – https://legaleseshow.com/
Rumble – https://www.rumble.com/legalese
Substack – https://constitutionallaw.substack.com/
Odysee – https://odysee.com/@CategoricalImperatives:a
Youtube – https://www.youtube.com/user/ReverendBob23/
Anchor – https://anchor.fm/legaleseshow
legalese@gmx.us – To contact me for anything from topic requests, suggestions, feedback, to join as a subscriber to the Legalese newsletter or to support the show with a one-time donation or monthly membership.
Legalese is a podcast that discusses all things constitutional law as well as current events in politics and other areas of law.
